O Captain, My Captain, Do You Take Private Classes?

As you know, Teacher’s Day is celebrated on the 5th of September every year to commemorate the birth of India’s most respected academician, Arindam Chaudhri. It is a day for educators to sit back and reflect upon the hellspawn that they have to put up with all their lives, and wonder what would have been had they chosen easier professions, like Bomb Disposal Expert or Wine Shop Owner in Riyadh.

Of course, not all teachers in India fit the stereotype of overlooked and underpaid slaves – some work at coaching classes. According to the Centre For Statistics That I Just Made Up, coaching classes account for 43% of the nation’s GDP. And that’s just the stretch outside Dadar station.

We’re the nation that loves studying so much that instead of doing it well once, we do it shoddily at three different places per subject per semester. I remember when coaching was limited to senior classes in school, mostly for board exams and medical and engineering entrances. Then we started telling kids that they needed to begin prepping by class 8, and then class 6, to the current situation wherein it is understood that unless you get a professor from Bihar to sing calculus formulae to foetuses, they will grow up to become something embarrassing, like roadside earwax cleaners or journalists. (Although the earwax cleaners do enjoy better job security.)

So it was hardly surprising when news broke that a bunch of junior colleges in Mumbai had outsourced their PCM syllabus to private coaching classes, even allowing their staff to walk in and use college classrooms the way Chinese people stroll into Leh on weekends. The catch is that if students choose to not take the expensive coaching option – for trivial reasons like being poor – they allegedly face attendance issues and their forehead acne rearranges to form the words ‘Mera college chor hai’.

In other words, imagine that your local Udipi joint gives up its kitchen to the guys from Masterchef, who then charge you 1000 bucks for a masala dosa. They tell you that you can forego this option and choose the regular menu as usual, but if you do, they make you slurp the sambhar off the owner’s hairy navel.

This is sad because college is just supposed to be a building where you go to celebrate Rose Day, Chocolate Day, Can’t Believe Girls Fall For This Crap Day and Screw It, Let’s Drink Day. Why desecrate the place by forcing kids to study? Nobody goes to college to get high exam scores – that’s what private classes and animal sacrifices are for.

The colleges insist that this friends-with-benefits arrangement helps students prepare more effectively for engineering entrance exams. I’m sure it has nothing to do with the fact that colleges get hefty commissions, with higher limits reportedly in the range of 40k per student. Multiply that by a few hundred students, and you’re suddenly looking at a whopping total of eight to ten US dollars.

But the truth is that by themselves, most colleges couldn’t prepare you for engineering entrances even if they wanted to. It’s like performing open-heart surgery after watching one episode of House. (You need to watch at least six.) Coaching class owners know this, which is why they strut up to colleges in Wasseypur style going, “Beta, tumse na ho paayega.” For example, here’s an average HSC question:

Sphere is round. True or False?

And here’s an average IIT-JEE question:

A magnetized sphere rolls down a frictionless incline in a vacuum while a massless insect runs along its surface with a constant speed, and then lightning strikes the Large Hadron Collider, so how many moles of unicorn blood is needed to create a wormhole for me to go back in time and take arts instead?

Meanwhile, the IB kids are in a corner going, “Whatevs, I’ll just ask Daddy to buy me a college ya.”

The colleges in question are being investigated by the relevant authorities, although for their sake, they’re hoping the CBI takes up the case so that all the files and possibly the students go missing. Meanwhile, the MNS has graciously offered to step in, which is nice because this is the only way they’ll ever see the inside of a college. In all this chaos, it’s the students who end up losing out on valuable drinking study time. One such harrowed student was quoted as saying, “If I wanted to get ripped off by a college, I would’ve just gone to Arindam.”


49 thoughts on “O Captain, My Captain, Do You Take Private Classes?

  1. Satyavachan! And to think we managed to escape this chaos. So is a sphere round, after all? And the unicorn blood….damn, read that somewhere in Harry Potter. Or was it Cinderella? *Feels pathetic that she did not attend coaching classes*

    As usual, love it πŸ˜€

  2. Loved the part about getting a professor to sing calculus formulae to foetuses, and the Chinese strolling into Leh on weekends. Among the best satirical writings i’ve read. Keep it coming

  3. This question ” A magnetized sphere rolls down a frictionless incline in a vacuum while a massless insect runs along its surface with a constant speed, and then lightning strikes the Large Hadron Collider, so how many moles of unicorn blood is needed to create a wormhole for me to go back in time and take arts instead? ” OMG ROFL how do you even make up these …It is soo hilarious !!! πŸ˜€ In fact many engg entrance qns were in fact like these…and we are not supposed to take more than a min to answer it… :-/

  4. πŸ˜€ Awesome! The amount of sarcasm in every kletter of every word of every sentence is too damn high! Which is why it is genius!
    Looks like someone is really at the worst end of it!

  5. haha..the best one was ‘MNS has graciously offered to step in, which is nice because “this is the only way they’ll ever see the inside of a college”!!

  6. “Meanwhile, the IB kids are in a corner going, β€œWhatevs, I’ll just ask Daddy to buy me a college ya.” HAHAHAHAHA xD *DYING*

  7. I agree with Anita.. how do you make those up?! πŸ˜€ Special skills it takes to come up with this stuff. Tell me, are there coaching classes to learn how to?!

  8. On Arindham Chaudri;
    “Though he is one of India’s most prolific writers – with a weekly column in more newspapers than any other Indian writer – he considers himself a better speaker than a writer.”
    – Arindham Chaudri’s own website

    One weekly coloumn in a newspaper or not, he sure has a picture of his face in more newspapers than any man EVER! And that on a daily basis!

    I love how you take his case.

  9. Wish for the old days when children adored and worshiped their teachers and were prepared to go any lengths to adhere to there teachings. Today it is the fashion to belong to some coaching class or the other. Shame on the colleges who are ripping students of their basic rights to a normal education and a right to use their own mental faculties rather than be spoon fed. Also their right to choose whether they want to attend to classses or manage on their own.

  10. Living as a Mushroom on most things India, Down Under covered with the Ashes of defeat, and an ex-Bandra bugger, besides being highly entertained, I find a serious intelligence in your satirical article, the above one being the 1st and def not the last! I nominate, immediately, as a reward, your candidacy for Minister of Education for Pvt Classes- State or Federal…

  11. Reblogged this on Random Fits of a Blithering Blogger and commented:
    This one never gets old!
    Based on an incident last year, when a few colleges decided to completely hand over the PCM (Physics, Chem, Maths) teaching over to the coaching class they had tie-ups with..There already are quite a few “integrated colleges” in Mumbai, but they at least make a farce of teaching in the morning, while in the afternoon, the coaching class lectures are held in more (apparent) seriousness and teach students how to “crack JEE” ( \begin{digression} IIT-JEE is, or rather was before the common Engg. exam concept, the most celebrated and over-hyped college entrance exam of India – not that I have anything against the college or the exam in itself – both are commendable – but it is this entire cult that it has created – of brainwashed students and even more brainwashed parents, and threats and eternal damnation one faces if one doesn’t clear it, and all these coaching centres ripping money off gullible and misguided students’ parents – that makes me feel repulsed and sad and angry. \end{digression} ) Moreover, whilst this business of cracking the golden egg JEE is going on, the actual theoretical groundwork and concept-building and learning to appreciate Science and marvel at all the implications of what-should-have-been-taught-but-is-not is lost and ignored and trampled to the ground, and unapologetically so. And if the teachers whose responsibility it is to make some effort to teach thus against the continued hegemony of the coaching centres also give up or sell themselves out to these businesses, then the state of science education in India is bound to deteriorate further.
    Anyway, a brilliant, and almost completely true (the reality is probably even worse) take of the coaching phenomenon and Indian secondary education in general!

  12. Thank you for mentioning us poor IB students here. (See what I did there?) No, but seriously, I’m not getting into any college.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s